Mercantile Bank sued for R350m over fraud conspiracy claims


Mercantile Bank CEO Karl Kumbler

Cape Town – Mercantile Bank has been taken to court over allegations that it conspired with an alleged fraudster in illegal asset stripping worth hundreds of millions of rand.

The bombshell litigation could not have come at a worse time, as the Portuguese-owned and South African-based bank is up for sale.

Alert Steel is seeking damages of R351m caused by Rayhaan Hassim, Mercantile Bank and West Lake Trade and Investments following what it believes was an illegal liquidation process in 2014. ArcelorMittal South Africa has joined Alert Steel as a second plaintiff in the matter.

Alert Steel’s counsel, Wim Trengove SC and Emmanuel Limberis SC, filed papers in the Johannesburg high court on Friday and included the Master of the Court as a defendant, as the court finalised the liquidation.

Portuguese bank Caixa Geral de Depósitos is in the process of selling Mercantile Bank, which has a balance sheet of R12.2bn and R2.2bn in capital.

Mercantile Bank told Fin24 on Monday that it “intends to rigorously defend the matter” as it believes the case is “fraught with factual inaccuracies”.

The alleged conspiracy

Detailing the conspiracy, Trengove and Limberis explain how Hassim, Mercantile Bank and others “conspired to devise and implement a scheme, to transfer the plaintiff’s business and all its assets to a new company held by Mr Hassim (West Lake); to pay the plaintiff’s loan liability to Mercantile Bank in full; and to put the plaintiff in liquidation”.

“The purpose of the scheme was to appropriate all the plaintiff’s assets for the benefit of Mr Hassim and Mercantile Bank at the expense of the plaintiff’s other creditors.”

As part of the conspiracy, they accuse Mercantile Bank of sending a letter to the plaintiff dated May 9 2014, “by which it unlawfully purported to cancel their loan agreement and demanded that the plaintiff immediately repay the full outstanding balance of the loan in an amount of R104m”.

The eventual sale of the liquidated assets to West Lake “was in fact only to the benefit of Mercantile Bank and highly prejudicial to all the plaintiff’s other creditors”, explain Trengove and Limberis.

After the sale, West Lake “acquired and continued to carry on the plaintiff’s erstwhile business. The parties to the conspiracy thus realised its purposes,” the plaintiffs argue.

They argue that the perfection agreement struck was a collusive transaction, transgressing the Insolvency Act. “The plaintiff entered into the perfection agreement in collusion with Mr Hassim and Mercantile Bank, before liquidation”, they argue.

Alert Steel wants the perfection agreement set aside, and wants the court to order Hassim and Mercantile Bank to repay it R251m plus interest.

Furthermore, Alert Steel – which is still alive as a firm – wants Mercantile Bank to forfeit its claim against Alert Steel and wants the bank to repay it R100m plus interest.

Mercantile Bank responds

Mercantile Bank CEO Karl Kumbier told Fin24 that it received the summons on Monday morning.

“Bearing in mind the timing and that this matter is sub judice, we cannot respond in detail to the allegations contained in the summons save to state that the allegations of conspiracy are rejected with contempt and that the other claims have no basis in law.

“We believe the summons is fraught with factual inaccuracies.

“We can confirm that Mercantile lent Alert R104m in the normal course of business. As any prudent lender would have done, the bank was entitled, and within its rights, to call in that loan when Alert breached the terms and conditions attached to it.

“That said, the bank worked with the business rescue practitioner for around two months to find a buyer for the whole or a part of the Alert business and, while a few well-known industry players showed interest, none proceeded with any offers to purchase the business or even part thereof.

“When the bank was advised of Alert’s imminent liquidation, external legal advice was sought and we perfected our general notarial bond. On Alert’s liquidation, six liquidators were appointed.

“The liquidators sourced the buyer after employing a sworn appraiser to value Alert’s assets (which were eventually sold at values in excess of those provided by the appraiser) and, on application by the liquidators, the Master of the High Court approved the sale of the assets.

“The bank did not recover all the money that it was owed by Alert.”

Article first appeared in http://www.fin24.com/Companies/Financial-Services/breaking-mercantile-bank-sued-for-r350m-over-fraud-conspiracy-claims-20170710

Fin24 will publish comment from Hassim shortly.

Show More

One Comment

  1. The Coalition of Civil Society for Change has expressed concern that unscrupulous persons
    are perfecting plans to undermine the anti-corruption efforts in the oil sector by making allegations that relations
    of the Minister of State for Petroleum, Dr. Ibe Kachikwu, are actively
    involved in the running of the Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation.
    The group at a press conference in Abuja on Tuesday, said those behind the campaign of calumny accused the minster’s brother, Dumebi Kachikwu, of channelling cash
    from the corporation to the opposition Peoples Democratic Party.

    The National President of the 14-member COSOC, Ibrahim Abubakar, said the allegations are meant to derail the anti-corruption fight by suggesting that President Muhammadu Buhari’s
    appointee are corrupt and using their family
    members to steal public funds.
    Ibrahim stressed: “As people who believed in President Muhammadu Buhari to bring about change when others were still sleeping, it will be wrong for us to go to bed and allow criminal elements within the People Democratic Party or any other political party or group to, through their agents, destroy the recent gains which the administration has made since its inauguration, particularly in the oil industry.
    “It is with great concerns that we therefore alert Nigerians to a plot to discredit the good work being done by Minister of State for Petroleum and Group Managing Director
    of NNPC, Mr Ibe Kachikwu. The plot includes sponsoring stories that would be branded
    as ‘exclusives’ to allege that the minister’s brother, Dumebi Kachikwu is unnecessarily meddling in the affairs of the NNPC.

    “Dumebi Kachikwu would be further accused of accumulating money earned from NNPC to fund the PDP on account of allegedly being a close associate of one of the party’s chieftains.
    “The people behind this campaign are agents being sponsored by the oil
    cabal who have become bitter because they no longer profit
    from the fraudulent subsidy regime as obtainable in the oil sector
    under the previous administration.
    “From our informal investigation, Kachikwu’s brother has no hand in any oil dealings or at anytime involved in sponsoring any member of the opposition, which by the way is in total disarray as a result of the ongoing war against corruption.”
    Ibrahim explained that the President knows the pedigree
    of the NNPC GMD before appointing him to such crucial position and
    that the desperate attempt to question his integrity by linking his relations to the running of the NNPC shows that the oil cabal has
    been dislodged.
    He noted: “Mr President made the right call by appointing a man who has unsettled the all powerful cabal. Kachikwu has proven to be a man that cannot be assailed with corrupt tendencies.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button
%d bloggers like this: