Blacks In Townships Are Worse-Off Than Whites In Farms

By Tiisetso Makhele

According to some individuals and groups, there is a genocide against Afrikaners in particular and whites in general in South Africa. A number of websites have been developed to raise people’s ‘awareness’ about such a genocide. Whilst we appreciate that any life lost is a tragedy, we must also be guided by empirical data before arriving at conclusions.

Except for horrendous images posted on these websites, no evidence of a genocide against Afrikaners or white farmers in South Africa has been advanced so far. Neither Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) nor the South African Police Service (SAPS) have made any scientific finding about white genocide.

Is there a case of white genocide in South Africa?

In 2014 Afriforum, an Afrikaner civil group, initiated a process to argue that farm attacks in the country are racially motivated. The group is also one of the organisations leading a charge that there is a white genocide in South Africa. The basis used by these organisations do not make scientific sense, and are often used to raise tensions amongst South Africans.

In the 2016/17 financial year, there were 74 people murdered on farms or smallholdings, and not all of those murdered were white. The argument that the farm attacks are racially motivated is not supported by facts and statistics.

Whilst we need to condemn the acts of violence against any person, including farmers and farm workers of whatever race, our ultimate goal must be to find lasting, rather than temporary solutions to this issue. In order to find sustainable solutions, we must deal with real problems, and not their symptoms.

In the same period mentioned above, there were 19 016 murders throughout South Africa. Statistically, the murders at farms and smallholdings constituted 0.4% of all murders in the 2016/17 financial year. Even if all the 74 murdered people were whites, the percentage would still be insignificant to suggest a genocide. So the argument of a genocide is not only opportunistic, but also dangerous.

The available data does not point to a genocide, nor intentional attacks on whites simply because they are white. The data from SAPS and Stats SA does, however, point to a very violent society. The available data also shows that a black person in the former township is more likely to be attacked or killed. It is therefore clear that we are dealing with a systemic problem of a violent society which is still reeling from the gruesome consequences of Apartheid and colonialism.

Violence as a consequence of Apartheid, alcohol abuse and skewed economic relations

According to a Crime Hotspot Analysis study done by the Institute of Security Studies (ISS), police stations in former townships recorded most violent crimes, including murders. The police station precincts in townships have experienced high murder rates for more than a decade, and such cycles may be difficult to undo. According to official data, Blacks in townships are more likely to be murdered that whites in farms. This factual picture contradicts the racially propelled propaganda advanced by Afriforum and other such organisations.

The creation by the racist Apartheid regime of townships was deliberate. The intention was to keep Africans and Blacks far away from ‘normal life’, and in social and economic ‘hell holes’. The current spatial and socio-economic patterns of townships bear the scars of our Apartheid past. The taverns that mushroom daily, even near schools, are as a result of the Bars and Shebeens that were constructed to ensure alcohol abuse was the major form of leisure for Blacks.

The support by the then regime of gangs was intended to inculcate a culture of violence amongst Blacks. It is common knowledge that the involvement of the Apartheid regime in the development of gangs still reflect in many of our townships today.

The fact that Blacks were dumped into townships, which were without any economic base, and subjected to stringent policies governing their ability to participate in the economy, created places stinking with destitution and poverty. Such poverty incensed the violent nature of the people who grew up in these townships. It is because of these material conditions that we have a present scenario.

Overhaul Apartheid make up and create balanced economic relations

The extent of violent crime in South Africa should be worrying for all of us. Whether it is a baby who is bludgeoned with an axe by his uncle, or a husband stabbed to death by his wife, or a farm worker killed by the farm owner, who claims to have mistaken the former for a monkey, crime must be discouraged.

Afriforum and other bodies must stop misleading people. There is no white genocide in South Africa. The high levels of violent crime and murder in South Africa need our utmost attention. Some of our townships are like war zones. Black lives matters, just like White lives. We must make all our areas safe for all South Africans. The skewed economic patterns must be altered, to minimize the risk of crime influenced by poverty and inequality. We all have a responsibility to arrest this situation. We must deal with our violent society, rather than raise unnecessary racial tensions.

Makhele is an African Marxist and an ANC member in Mangaung, Free State. He writes in his personal capacity. 

Show More

One Comment

  1. Re: Blacks in townships are more unsafe than white in farms

    Cde Makhele, I have always maintained that the developments which are unfolding at the socio-economic and political spheres are chiefly determined by the manner in which we attained the democratic breakthrough – what others call freedom – I know not what we are free from because the apartheid legacy is ravaging our land. This informs the existence and posture of far-right neo-Nazist groupings like AfriForum who are having a field day to perpetrate racially-laden lies in the interest of self-preservation. It is my lived experience that black life is cheap in this land; no amount of Charterism can alter this reality. I need no statistics to know this because it affects me directly. Again, is it not a paradox that whites who stay in black townships are more safe from different forms of attacks than blacks who stay in white areas? In his initial volume i.e. Between the World and Me, Ta-nehisi Coates illustrates with realism how the black body is a subject of brutalization by systemic racism. Whiteness is institutionalized; at various levels it is the very essence of modernity. Let me also appreciate that you choose to refer to yourself as an African Marxist. I hope those who dismiss the relevance of accentuating the fact of blackness in this world do not tire from doing some soul searching. Again, Uncensored Opinion is proving to be a growing powerful “disruptive” platform. Liberalism must fall!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button
%d bloggers like this: