All Black Lives Matter – even the 462 that died at Life Esidimeni

By Pinky Khoabane


“Life Esidimeni (meaning a place of dignity)’ is how the website of the health facility in the news recently defines its service.


Only in South Africa perhaps do you kill 462 lives and present the notion of dignity. Actually, in our discourse you can kill that many Black lives and the South African media, depending on who you are, can overlook your murderers spree.

Dignity presents a number of meanings, none precise, but we recognise dignity when we see it. Dignity in healthcare would require that there’s mutual respect between the service provider and the patient. We all know that with dignity comes respect and there’s a sense of self-worth which must play a major role in recovery – from any illness.

If there is a group of patients who never receive dignity from both the health care providers and the public at large, it is mental health patients. We all know that mental health patients are demeaned, stigmatised and discriminated – even by the healthcare workers who are supposed to care for them.

To boldly offer a statement that dignity is what it offers, Life Esidemeni would have to do better than have on its records the deaths 462 patients who died between September 2011 and May 2016.

But perhaps more importantly, we would have to ask why Health Ombudsman Melagapuru Makgoba omitted this very important statistic. In 2012 alone, 109 patients  at this suddenly “great” facility died. In 2011, 130 people died. This happened without any outrage because generally, this is how the public thinks of Black lives – many die in public hospitals and as is now proven, even in this fake place of dignity – and nobody cares.

Black lives are determined by a political and media agenda. I’ve said this over and over, miners, for example – Black – die all the time underground and as a result of toxic waste from mines – and you will not hear Sipho Pityana or most of the people who supposedly care for Black Lives utter a word. Mines send their workers back home to die….with silicosis, TB, and injuries they get in the line of duty. And they have no one to fight for them because the unions have been captured by white monopoly capitalists and some in the ruling party are shareholders in those mines.

A hundred Black lives, transferred from Life Esidemeni to NGOs  in 2016 were lost – and this is tragic. In any country which values life, the uproar is warranted but we are a country where, unless there’s political mileage made, the commercial media and their handlers, couldn’t give a hoot.

Only in South Africa will you have a minister – as Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi has done – decide to return patients to a place of death. Like the health ombudsman, Motsoaledi has conveniently forgotten the 462 lives lost at Life Esidimeni.




Show More


  1. Only in SA will this happen. Its not only in this department that the poor ignored, its allover and e might as well divide SA ib Demo Apartheid SA, the country where only those who have,those who know someone or are known survive

    1. So true Rachel. Simply unbelievable that the 462 lives don’t matter. Life Esidimeni has the connected people involved and so when they lost the tender, they had to ensure the 100 who died in the care of others captured news while their deaths were completely ignored.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top button

For As Little As A Monthly Donation or Subscription of R150,00 You can Keep UnCensored Alive

For those of you who read UnCensored regularly, we implore you to donate. For those who donate, we thank you greatly. 

%d bloggers like this: