FAKE NEWS: Citizen’s report on Bathabile Dlamini typical example of manufactured NEWS

bathabile-dlamini

By Pinky Khoabane

The Citizen reported this morning that Minister of Social Development and ANC Women’s League addressed a crowd “allegedly drunk”.

bathabile-dlamini

And so how does this apartheid mouthpiece know this?

“According to those who were reportedly in attendance at the event at the Germiston Civic Centre in Ekurhuleni on Friday, the minister was allegedly “unsteady on her feet'”. This paper couldnt even confirm that its sources were indeed at the event. They were “reportedly” (just another word for allegedly) there which leaves doubt in the mind of the reader whether they were there or not.  And who reportedly made these allegations? The most powerful source of today’s newspapers no doubt – the anonymous source.

The paper continues: “Some people reportedly left without seeing her as she was three hours late and those who were patient enough to wait for her were not impressed with her speech as it was unrelated to the topic at hand.” Just when you’d expect that her speech would be described as slurred as proof of the headline – No, it was just allegedly not in line with the expectations of those who “reportedly remained.” You’d think the reader would be told what topic she was expected to deliver and what she presented but facts must never stand in the way of gossip and such information may just do that.

And what is the evidence of the minister’s drunk behaviour then?

She was “allegedly unsteady on her feet” is the only evidence advanced by the Citizen. Oh, there was another incident where she allegedly cried at an election campaign for being “disrespected” which left some “wondering if she was drunk”. Notice how allegedly has been replaced with “wondering if”?

If there was a word more misused in journalism it is “alleged”. It has ceased to be a phrase used to protect the rights of an accused in a crime but is now being used to avoid litigation by lazy journalists and newspapers hell-bent on smearing individuals. Even in the case of an accused, once it’s known he’s the perpetrator, it can no longer be alleged. Murderer Oscar Pistorius remained an alleged killer for days – even after his confession that he had killed Reeva Steenkamp. And so the media will selectively use this word when it protects its blue-eyed idols and to vilify its enemies.

To allege means making claims without offering proof. And so to put an adverb allegedly or adjective alleged in front of negative characterisation of an individual doesnt make the damnation any lesser.

A closer inspection of The Citizen’s story shows the extent to which the journalist went to smear Dlamini.

Dlamini was “allegedly unsteady on her feet”. The point is she either was or she was not and because there is no further proof,  the Citizen decided to cover its tracks and use the word alleged. I’m not a lawyer but this statement would not stand in a court of law.

While the usage of this word may keep journalists out of court, it does nothing for the accuracy of the story and credibility of newspapers and that is if there is still such a thing as credibility and integrity in newspapers. The losers are the victims of the alleged incidents who have no means of recourse. The paper will print a small apology somewhere in the inside pages and if Dlamini approaches the press ombudsman, The Citizen will have a small slap on the wrist by way of an apology but by then, the perception has been made that Dlamini is a drunkard.

 

 

 

11 Comments on "FAKE NEWS: Citizen’s report on Bathabile Dlamini typical example of manufactured NEWS"

  1. “And so how does this apartheid mouthpiece…” the statement is misleading, the Citizen WAS an apartheid propaganda tool But not today…now you falling in the same trap as the journalist who wrote that Citizen article. Good work but avoid praise-singing and report on censored news.

    • Pinky Khoabane | January 10, 2017 at 1:45 pm | Reply

      What does the citizen stand for today? For a progressive newspaper? You gotta be kidding. And as for praise-singing, please look up the phrase.

    • You must really be joking Azariel, you must be not a South African if you do not know the fact that the mainstream media is captured…e.g. Motale’s dismissal from Citizen is political and has everything to do with the preservation of a specific narrative that protects white monopoly capitalists and their cronies from scrutiny in the state capture debate.

  2. Perhaps we as people deserves this “small slap on the wrist by way of an apology” which is currently enjoyed by White-owned media outlets, I will apologise afterwards regarding my reporting below:

    1. P.W. Botha allegedly died of complications of STIs.
    2. Helen Zille was allegedly drunk-driving during festive season.
    3. Cyril Ramaphosa was allegedly drunk when he reportedly ordered the murder of Marikana mine workers.
    4. Mainstream media editors are allegedly addicted to cocaine.
    5. Etc.

    I apologise…

    • Pinky Khoabane | January 10, 2017 at 1:59 pm | Reply

      Hehehe, K.M.
      I reportedly found your alleged article highly amusing and clever. I suspect you will end up in hot water if we were to publicly disclose these juicy allegations. Oops, no you have apologised….all is well. LOL.

      Kindest
      PK

  3. The use of anonymous sources has conveniently enabled white media to create and progate anti-govt narratives meant to promote DA and white capitalists’ interests. It is also interesting to note that some of these sources are paraded as experts but still remain anonymous. As for the words alleged or allegedly their overuse now borders on insanity. But it still remains unfair to the victim as you rightly said. As an aside l am still waiting for the serialisation and public ventilation of the CIEX Report by the mainstream media. Or am l dreaming?

    • Pinky Khoabane | January 10, 2017 at 6:48 pm | Reply

      Dear Methu. Look there was a need to protect sources hence anonymity was important. But as you say, it has gone to levels of insanity. As for alleged and allegedly, no comment.

      Kindest

      PK

    • Pinky Khoabane | January 10, 2017 at 6:55 pm | Reply

      I think the CIEX will make news depending on whether the PP will reopen the case to include the aspect of recovering the money stolen. Thuli Madonsela changed the complaint from investigating the conduct of the ANC only and not pursuing issue of recovering the money.

  4. When persons are three hours late I get pi**ed.

    Concur with he abuse of “alleged, allegedly”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*